Following is an excerpt of an interview by Selcuk Sirin (Associate Professor of Applied Psychology at New York University – Steinhardt School of Culture, Education and Human Development) with Al Jazeera Turkey. Dr. Sirin is a statistician who works on social development and education, and is also author of the book “Yol Ayrimindaki Turkiye” (Turkey at Crossroads). His research interests and publications can be found here.
In this article (published by author’s permission), Dr. Sirin shares his view the challenges Turkey faces in governance, technology development and critical thinking.
Critical Thinking and Decision Making
According to Dr. Sirin, Turkey’s main problem is the governance of decision-making. Decisions in Turkey are made through ideological lenses, whereas it should involve more data, as is the case in the developed economies. Dr. Sirin argues that Turkey cannot develop its own technology, for which critical thinking is a prerequisite. Emergence of technology and innovation does not only depend on greater investments in R&D. After all, it is people who will develop technology. And the root of innovation is the free existence of criticism.
As the chart below demonstrates, Turkey is not in a good position when it comes to critical thinking. According to OECD survey executed among 15 years old children, percentage of critical thinkers in Turkey is 2,2% while the OECD average is 12%. Same rate is 28% in South Korea, home of global brands such as Samsung.
Source: OECD PISA (Programme For International Student Assessment) Report - 2012
Economy and Branding
Dr. Sirin takes a broad view regarding application of technology and argues that it should not be confined to the use of computes. Instead, Turkish private sector should focus on high-value added productions. In today’s world, it is necessary to add wisdom, logic, art, creativeness and design into everything we do. There are only few differences between smart phones in terms technical specifications, but iPhone is the most popular due its unique design.
"In today’s world, it is necessary to add wisdom, logic, art, creativeness and design into everything we do."
There is no Turkish brand in the top 500 global brands. This is caused by lack of investment in art. For instance, 80% of hazelnuts are produced in Turkey but Nutella is not a Turkish brand. The industrial segment in textile is much more developed in Turkey than Italy. However, Turkey does not have a global brand sold in international boutiques. The same goes for agriculture and tourism, which are among the most important economic sources. Turkey will remain backwards if it cannot add high value to these sectors.
Quality of Education and Middle Income Trap
While sharing his opinion on education and development, Dr. Sirin makes comparison between Turkey and other countries that manage to get over the middle-income trap. Countries such as Japan, Finland and South Korea developed their education and industry in a progressive and gradual way. Japan followed-up the developments in US during 1970s and created her way in technology. Japan produced the first digital devices, aiming to be a player in the new game. This case is almost similar in the other countries, achieving to create value and getting through the middle-income trap.
Turkey should follow a similar path to become a player in the new industrial revolution. As for the education part, Finland started to make a long-term investment on education starting from 1970s when 70% of Finnish population used to live in rural areas. However, Finland’s GDP per capita is now 30-40.000 USD thanks to prior investments on R&D and innovation as well as critical thinking mentality given during the primary school period. On the other hand, the average student in Turkey scored 462 in reading literacy, maths and sciences, lower than the OECD average of 497. Therefore, Turkey should invest in education to become a player in the new industrial age - by jumping through the middle-income trap and gaining a competitive edge.
UNDP - Education Index 2013
Comment & Questions
We would like to hear your thoughts on this report. Please get in touch with us.
StratejiCo. is an independent Turkish corporate and public affairs consultancy firm, providing trusted advice to multinational companies and government institutions in Eurasia since 1987.
This report is prepared by StratejiCo. based on the information gathered from publicly available sources. Opinions and views expressed in this view does not reflect StratejiCo.’s official view. The purpose of this content is to provide our readers with different perspectives about their businesses. StratejiCo. cannot be hold liable or responsible for the decisions based on the information provided here.